Support our Soldiers

19 Apr 2008

Coldstream Guards return home from Afghanistan

A Military Operations news article

18 Apr 08

Soldiers from 1 Company 1st Battalion Coldstream Guards returned home to a heroes welcome last night, 17 April 2008, at the end of a six month tour of duty in Afghanistan.

Lance Corporal Alex Duncan

Coldstream Guard Lance Corporal Alex Duncan kisses his daughter Jessica at Victoria Barracks, Windsor, following his return to the UK from Afghanistan
[Picture: Cpl Richard Cave RLC]

Family and friends gathered on the parade square at Victoria Barracks, Windsor, the UK home of the 1st Battalion Coldstream Guards, eagerly awaiting the arrival of loved ones. Amid emotional scenes, there were cheers, hugs and kisses for the British Army's longest serving regiment as they disembarked their coaches.

Lieutenant Colonel George Waters, Commanding Officer, said:

"1 Company has just returned from a demanding six month tour, but a hugely rewarding one. The main task of 1 Company had been to stabilise the UK sector in Kabul, supporting our Afghan and NATO allies as well as British national interests. I think, without being complacent, that we can look back on six months' work really well done. I am hugely proud of what the men of 1 Company have achieved."

The Guards' mission in Kabul was one of stabilisation, traditionally one of the most dangerous, by denying insurgents the freedom to operate. They were also the Quick Reaction Force (QRF) for all UK assets in the city, and the operations company of choice for the multi-national, Italian-led Regional Command Capital.

Since the Coldstream Guards arrived in Kabul in October 2007, part of the wider (ISAF) mission in Afghanistan, they have seen the situation in and around Kabul improve, much to the benefit and relief of local people.

Major Hennessy Barrett, 1 Company Commander, explained that their success has been about building strong relationships within the community:

Members of 1 Company 1st Battalion Coldstream Guards

Members of 1 Company 1st Battalion Coldstream Guards arriving back in the UK
[Picture: Cpl Richard Cave RLC]

"We have tried to blend security and consent-winning activities, or rather humanitarian activities, so that we are improving security but also making life better for the people of Kabul. We have been very fortunate in having a number of effects on the insurgency here, namely a marked decline in the terrorist incidents within the British sector."

Humanitarian successes included the provision of free health checks as well as medicines and ointments to all Kabul residents. This resulted in 1 Company bringing relief and medical treatment to over 5,000 Afghans during their tour.

Reconstruction and development successes included the building of a footbridge, a product of the combined efforts of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) and the Coldstream Guards Civilian and Military Cooperation (CIMIC) team. It was completed in just six weeks and spans the Jalalabad road in Kabul, providing a safe route for children to get to the Qabel Bey School.

Speaking of the Coldstream Guards return to the UK, Major Hennessy Barrett added:

"I think firstly and foremostly we are overjoyed to be home with our wives and loved ones. We are having a homecoming parade through Windsor which will be a great honour and privilege to be part of and afterwards I think we will enjoy some well earned post-operational leave."

The parade through Windsor is due to take place on Saturday 26 April 2008 when the Colonel of the Regiment, Sir General Michael Rose, and the Mayor of Windsor, Councillor Leo Walters, will take the salute on the steps of the Guildhall.

Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone and Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson killed in Afghanistan

A Military Operations news article

15 Apr 08

It is with great sadness that the Ministry of Defence must confirm the deaths of Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone of the Royal Air Force Regiment and Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson of the Royal Auxiliary Air Force Regiment on Sunday 13 April 2008 in Afghanistan.

Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone and Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson

Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone (left) and Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson
[Picture: MOD]

The Support Weapons Flight of 3 Squadron RAF Regiment was undertaking a patrol to protect NATO's Kandahar Airfield from enemy attack in the Daman District of Kandahar province. At 1848 hours local time, the vehicle that they were travelling in was caught in an explosion. SAC Livingstone and SAC Thompson were both extracted to the field hospital at Kandahar Airfield, but sadly died as a result of their wounds.

Two other servicemen were injured in the blast, however their injuries are not life threatening and one has subsequently returned to duty.

Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingston

Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone
[Picture: MOD]

Senior Aircraftman Graham 'Livi' Livingstone

Senior Aircraftman Graham Keter Livingstone, aged 23, was born on 17 November 1984 in Glasgow. He initially joined the Royal Marines for a short period in 2003, before joining the Royal Air Force on 17 October 2004.

After completion of his basic training, SAC Livingstone became a trainee gunner on 13 December 2004. He was posted onto 3 Squadron RAF Regiment at Aldergrove on 4 March 2005, and moved with the Squadron when they were relocated to RAF Wittering in the spring of 2007. He was promoted to Senior Aircraftman on 17 October 2005 and whilst with 3 Squadron he served in Iraq in 2006 and deployed to Afghanistan on 22 February 2008.

SAC Livingstone's mother, Rosemary O'Neil, said:

"Graham was a much loved father, son and brother. He died doing a job he loved. As a family we are very proud and he will be sadly missed."

Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson

Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson
[Picture: MOD]

Senior Aircraftman Gary 'Tommo' Thompson

Senior Aircraftman (SAC) Gary Thompson, aged 51, was born on 15 October 1956. SAC Thompson joined the Royal Air Force in November 1973 as a Supplier and duly left the Service in October 1977 to pursue a civilian career.

He subsequently joined No 504 (County of Nottingham) Squadron Royal Auxiliary Air Force on 19 March 2005. After successful completion of his Basic Gunner Course in May 2006 he was given the badge of a RAF Regiment Gunner. He went on to complete a Mortar Cadre Course with 3 Squadron RAF Regiment in February 2007 and was mobilised on 29 October 2007, where he was assigned to Support Weapons Flight. He was promoted to Senior Aircraftman on 1 March 2008. SAC Thompson deployed to Kandahar Air Field with 3 Squadron, RAF Regiment on 22 February 2008.

In civilian life, SAC Thompson was Managing Director of Sherwood Ducting Ltd, in Nottingham. He leaves behind, his wife Jacqui and their five daughters, Laurie, 24, Aimee, 22, Jordan, 20, Jade, 17 and Kelly, 16.

The Family of SAC Thompson said:

"A devoted husband, father, son and brother who touched the lives of everyone who knew him; Gary was more than our hero, he was the rock and foundation of our family. Words cannot express how much he was loved and how proud of him we are. Gary, you have had our hearts from the beginning and now they are yours forever."

"The loss of "Tommo" and "Livi" is a tragic blow to all who knew, trained and fought alongside them. Both men were immensely popular and professional, and the humour both brought to the Squadron was immeasurable."

Officer Commanding 3 Squadron RAF Regiment, Squadron Leader Richard Langley

Officer Commanding 3 Squadron RAF Regiment, Squadron Leader Richard Langley said:

"Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson was a reservist serving with 504 Squadron Royal Auxiliary Air Force, he had trained with 3 Squadron Royal Air Force Regiment throughout 2007, and had become a Mortarman.

"He was the consummate professional soldier and airman, who took immense pride in his military service in addition to his civilian job as manager of Sherwood Ducting Ltd. Upon joining 3 Squadron RAF Regiment on mobilisation, Gary was re-named "Tommo". Fitting in immediately, his skills and humour were such that all held him in the highest regard. "Tommo" was not one to seek the attention, but was the voice of calm and reason who continuously supported the Squadron's less experienced gunners. He was immensely proud to serve with the Squadron, as we were to serve alongside him, and he will be sorely missed by all.

"Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone was 23 years old, from Strathclyde, Scotland. Better known to the Squadron as "Livi", he was one of the brightest characters on the Squadron. Having served in Iraq, Northern Ireland and Afghanistan, he was a very operationally experienced gunner, and his professionalism showed in all that he did. Always with a smile, a throw away line and a gag, Livi's humour was at the heart of Support Weapons Flight. He was one of us and his loss has been deeply felt by us all.

"The loss of "Tommo" and "Livi" is a tragic blow to all who knew, trained and fought alongside them. Both men were immensely popular and professional, and the humour both brought to the Squadron was immeasurable. "Tommo" and "Livi" will be terribly missed by their colleagues in the RAF Regiment here in Kandahar, but also in Basra and in the UK. We will honour their memory by standing resolute in our duty to Afghanistan in the manner they embodied with determination and pride. Our thoughts and prayers are with their families and friends at this tragic time."

Commanding Officer 1 RAF Force Protection Wing, Wing Commander Scott Miller said:

"SAC Graham Livingstone was an immensely popular member of Support Weapons Flight on 3 Squadron RAF Regiment. His fine sense of humour and positive character played a key role in maintaining the morale of his colleagues whilst facing the dangerous and challenging, but vital mission in defence of Kandahar Airfield. Graham was the sort of Gunner who, with high professional skill and deep determination, sought to keep others safe, irrespective of the personal cost. He invariably put the needs of his friends and colleagues first. He will be sorely missed.

"SAC Gary Thompson was a highly respected Auxiliary Gunner who enriched 1 RAF Force Protection Wing with his presence. His enthusiasm and the popularity that he enjoyed on 504 Squadron Royal Auxiliary Air Force travelled with him when he was mobilized to join 3 Squadron RAF Regiment. He was always willing to give the younger members of Support Weapons Flight on 3 Squadron the benefit of his considerable wisdom and as much help as he could. The energy with which he approached his work belied his age and set an example for those around him. The respect he earned was obvious for all to see. Tommo's death will leave a big gap on both 3 Squadron and 504 Squadron."

Commander Kandahar Airfield, Air Commodore Bob Judson said:

"Both SAC Graham Livingstone and SAC Gary Thompson were bright lights in a vibrant and enthusiastic RAF Regiment Squadron that is utterly focused and professional in discharging the difficult and dangerous task of providing the outer layer of protection and security at Kandahar Airfield. These two enthusiastic, brave, popular and capable men have made the ultimate sacrifice whilst giving their best; their loss will be keenly felt by all on this base but most especially the members of No 1 Force Protection Wing and No 3 Squadron RAF Regiment. The bright lights may have been dimmed but they will never be forgotten and my thoughts are very much with both Gary's and Graham's families at this most difficult of times."

"Graham Livingstone and Gary Thompson became Royal Air Force Regiment Gunners and to the end they were the true spirit of an RAF Regiment Gunner – they were Fighting, Thinking, Winning Gunners. They were a sure defence to all they served."

Warrant Officer Garry Eden, Squadron Warrant Officer, No 3 Squadron RAF Regiment

Officer Commanding Support Weapons Flight, 3 Sqn RAF Regiment, Flight Lieutenant Andy Costin said:

"Graham 'Livi' Livingstone was a cheeky Gunner who could always quip with a remark. He excelled as a Number 1 on my Mortar Flight. Our standing joke on the Support Weapons Flight was that he was always to be last in charge. The challenge for me as his flight commander was to make use of his abundant enthusiasm and steer it in the best possible direction. He found that direction as my Signaller, always performing his duties to the utmost. Livi is going to be sorely missed upon the Flight and the Squadron.

"Gary 'Tommo' Thompson joined the Squadron and came to Support Weapons Flight, here he learnt the skills required to fire the 81mm mortar. He mastered these well and very quickly. In spite of the additional years he had on the rest of the Flight he was never one to shy away from anything. His dedication to his work was clearly demonstrated when Tommo took me through an ingenious training facility that he had set up entirely under his own initiative. He was a very active member within the flight always organising something. His dedication and devotion to his family could not be over estimated. We will miss him. Per Ardua."

Squadron Warrant Officer, No 3 Squadron RAF Regiment, Warrant Officer Garry Eden said:

"Graham Livingstone and Gary Thompson became Royal Air Force Regiment Gunners and to the end they were the true spirit of an RAF Regiment Gunner – they were Fighting, Thinking, Winning Gunners. They were a sure defence to all they served."

Tributes to Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson from Senior Aircraftman Jim Murphy, Corporal Errol Robinson and Corporal Sean Langston-Jones, fellow members of 504 Sqn Royal Auxiliary Air Force mobilised onto 3 Squadron RAF Regiment:

"We remember when we first met Gary, on the Trainee Gunners Course of 504 Squadron Royal Auxiliary Air Force and from that very first day we knew he was the kind of person that was determined to strive for the best in life and to be a success in everything that he put his hand to.

"One would think that Gary being from Nottingham would support his home town, but no, he supports the one and only Man United, obviously mixed loyalties. He was a keen rugby fan and player.

"Gary was one of the most approachable and friendliest of people we know, we never once heard him have anything negative said of anyone. He was a proud father of his five daughters and a proud husband of his wife Jacqui; he was always talking about his family and how much he missed them. He had such a huge circle of family and friends that he became the envy of the flight by the amount of e-blueys and parcels that he received, but deep down we didn't mind as he was like a father figure to us all.

"Gary, during our trainee gunners course was nicknamed 'Gary Gortex' because he was always wearing his waterproofs on the ranges, even if it wasn't raining, the name continued to stick with him at 504 Sqn and he was proud of it. On Support Weapons of 3 Squadron, he became known as "Tommo", to which he became proud of, and to most of the flight this is how he will be remembered.

"Gary had the ability to notice when others around him are feeling under the weather or feeling sad, on occasions during this tour he had always noticed when one of us had been down, even though we tried to hide our emotions from him, with this compassion you were always left feeling better within yourself.

"It goes without saying, everyone who has crossed paths with Gary in one way or another will be sad to learn that he is no longer with us, however, his spirit will always remain with us, on behalf of Support Weapons Flight we all feel proud to have known him.

"Gary will be truly missed by us all.

"Rest in Peace"

Tributes to Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone from the Lads of Support Weapons Flight, 3 Squadron RAF Regiment:

"Livi was an avid Celtic supporter from the outskirts of Glasgow. A keen driver and amateur DJ, he joined the RAF Regiment at the age of 20 and was posted to 3 Sqn. He was employed on C Flight where he soon proved himself to be an accomplished marksman, selected to be a sharpshooter, he took pride in his ability to master weapon systems. He then went on to Support Weapons Flt where he quickly found he had a skill for the 81mm Mortar, achieving excellent results on his Basic Mortar Cadre; he was quickly elevated to the No 1 position of number 2 Det, it was clear he had found his place. Livi was employed as the Flight Commander's signaller and was responsible for the communications on three different operating systems keeping the Flight Commander current and situationally aware.

"Graham leaves behind Kyle his young son. Never shy to speak his mind, Livi was adept at throw away statements. His fervent willingness to improve himself, be an asset to his flight and to keep the morale of the troops up, even at his own expense, will be sorely missed. And for us all, never again to say, 'SHUT UP LIVI.'"

Defence Secretary Des Browne said:

"I was greatly saddened by the tragic loss of Senior Aircraftman Graham Livingstone and Senior Aircraftman Gary Thompson. They were both extremely well liked and popular airmen and will be sorely missed by all who knew them. My thoughts and prayers are with their family and friends at what must be the most difficult of times."

Both families have requested that the media respect their need for privacy at this difficult time.

6 Apr 2008

52 Brigade troops begin returning from Afghanistan

A Military Operations news article

3 Apr 08

The first British troops from 52 Infantry Brigade have begun to arrive back at their home bases in the UK after a six month tour in Afghanistan.

Pte Saye embraces his partner

Private Paul Saye, 2 YORKS, embraces his partner Lisa Barker
[Picture: Kevin Hegarty]

In Edinburgh, troops from 52 Infantry Brigade Headquarters arrived back at the city's Redford Barracks. Under the command of Brigadier Andrew Mackay, the Brigade deployed as part of the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) in October 2007 and commanded the 7,000-strong NATO Task Force Helmand.

In theatre, 52 Brigade has been responsible for training and mentoring the Afghan National Army (ANA) and the Afghan National Police (ANP). Together with the Afghan National Army, the Brigade successfully planned and led the biggest NATO operation since 2001 - Operation MAR KARADAD - to remove the Taliban from Musa Qaleh.

There were tears of emotion at Weeton Camp in Lancashire as families turned out to welcome troops from the 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment (Green Howards) (2 YORKS) who started to arrive home from theatre yesterday, 2 April 2008. 2 YORKS have been attached to 52 Brigade and deployed to Afghanistan with the force in October 2007. Lieutenant Colonel Simon Downey, Commanding Officer, said:

"The battalion has just returned from a demanding six month tour, but a hugely rewarding one. Our main task has been to train the Afghan National Army so that that Army can take on the responsibility for security for its own people. I think, without being complacent, that we can look back on six-months' work really well done. I am hugely proud of what the men and women of the 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment have achieved over the last six months.

HQ 52 Bde personnel

Left to Right: WO2 Lisa Mcleod, Major Dai Bevan, Captain Lenny Gill and WO2 Jo Lamb, all of HQ 52 Brigade, relax among the spring daffodils of Edinburgh
[Picture: Mark Owens, MOD]

"The support we have had has been superb. When you are far away from home and you are operating in some pretty difficult and dangerous and austere conditions, the support and thought that you receive from people at home makes a significant difference."

This has been a gruelling tour for the Battalion which suffered the tragic loss of two of its young men in two separate incidents during the deployment. Sergeant Lee Johnson, from Stockton-on-Tees, was killed by an explosive device whilst taking part in Operation MAR KARADAD in Musa Qaleh on 8 December 2007; and Corporal Damian Stephen Lawrence, from Whitby, had been taking part in a joint patrol with the Afghan National Army in Kajaki when a device exploded in one of the compounds they had been investigating. He was killed instantly.

And finally, in Reading, the 96 Territorial Army soldiers and 44 regulars of Salonika Company, 7th Battalion The Rifles Regiment, returned to a heroes' welcome as proud families and partners joined the Battalion's Royal Colonel, Her Royal Highness The Duchess of Gloucester, and Armed Forces Minister Bob Ainsworth to greet their loved ones at Brock Barracks.

A military band played as the 140 men and women of Salonika Company marched onto the parade square to receive their Operation HERRICK medals from the Duchess of Gloucester and the Commander of Regional Forces, Lieutenant General Nick Parker CBE.

In Afghanistan, the Company had been charged with defending the British base at Camp Bastion, but ended up getting a lot more from their tour. 7 RIFLES' Commanding Officer, Lieutenant Colonel Damian Griffin explained:

"The troops were sent out primarily to defend Camp Bastion, but they did that so effectively and were so keen to do more that they ended up serving on almost every British operation going on out there."

Salonika Coy homecoming parade

Lieutenant General Nick Parker CBE presents Op HERRICK medals to soldiers of Salonika Company, 7 RIFLES, at Brock Barracks in Reading
[Picture: Corporal Adrian Harlen, RLC]

Lieutenant General Parker addressed the Territorial soldiers of Salonika Company on the parade square with the following message of thanks:

"I am extraordinarily grateful to every one of you for volunteering to take part in the tour and for the efforts you have made on our behalf. You return at the start of the centenary celebrations of the Territorial Army, TA 100, and in doing so demonstrate everything that is good about today's reserve forces.

"Your contribution is recognised by the medals you now wear and by The Duchess of Gloucester's gracious agreement to present them. Thank you for all you have done, and enjoy the post operational tour leave that you have all most definitely earned. After that, when you return to your various places of work, I am sure that you will show your employers that your time with Salonika Company has made a profound difference. The country, the Army, the Regiment and all of us represented here today are proud of you."

52 Brigade troops will continue to return to their home bases over the next few weeks as they are gradually replaced by personnel deploying for the next roulement under Operation HERRICK 8. 16 Air Assault Brigade will officially take over command of Helmand province from 52 Brigade later in April 2008.

4 Apr 2008

More UK troops may be sent to Afghanistan


By James Kirkup in Bucharest
Last Updated: 2:19am BST 04/04/2008

Gordon Brown is preparing to send hundreds more British troops to Afghanistan, taking the numbers there above 8,000 for the first time.


US President George W. Bush and British Prime Minister Gordon Brown at the NATO Summit conference in  Bucharest
There did not seem to be great chemistry between President George Bush and Gordon Brown at the start of the summit in Bucharest

The Prime Minister is currently considering advice from the Ministry of Defence to increase the force amid concern that Britain's Nato allies are still not doing enough to support the international mission.

The additional forces would be mainly intended to bolster reconstruction and development work with some soldiers helping train the Afghan National Army and support the Afghan police.

At present, there are 47,000 Nato troops in Afghanistan from more than 40 countries.

However, the lion's share of the most dangerous work is done by Britain, the US, Canada and Denmark. At the Nato summit in Bucharest, France confirmed that it will send around 1,000 more troops.

They will deploy in the relatively stable east of the country, allowing US Marines to move to the turbulent south where British forces are based.

The French pledge was enough to persuade the Canadians to back down from a threat to pull their forces out of southern Afghanistan, something commanders say would have seriously undermined the Nato mission.

But British military insiders said that France and other European nations are still insisting upon "caveats" - conditions as to where their forces can be deployed and in what operations they can take part.

"There has been no substantial progress on the caveats yet, which is unfortunate," said a senior British military source, adding that such conditions only add to the burden on Britain. "The more that others do, the less pressure there is on us to do these things."

Ninety-one British personnel have been killed in Afghanistan since 2001. The current force numbers about 7,800.

A Downing Street spokesman said that British troop numbers are under "constant review."


Lieutenant John Thornton and Marine David Marsh killed in Afghanistan

A Military Operations news article

1 Apr 08

It is with deep sadness that the Ministry of Defence must confirm the deaths of Lieutenant John Thornton and Marine David Marsh, both of 40 Commando Royal Marines, in southern Afghanistan on Sunday 30 March 2008.

Lieutenant John 'JT' Thornton RM [Picture: MOD]

Lieutenant John 'JT' Thornton RM
[Picture: MOD]

Just after 1653 hours local time, the Marines were conducting a patrol in the vicinity of Kajaki, Helmand province, when the vehicle they were travelling in was caught in an explosion.

Medical treatment was provided prior to both being evacuated to the field hospital at Camp Bastion. Despite the best efforts of the medical team, both sadly died as a result of their wounds.

Lieutenant John 'JT' Thornton

Lieutenant John 'JT' Thornton, aged 22, was from Ferndown in Dorset and joined the Royal Marines on 31 August 2004. He had previously served in Iraq and leaves behind his loving parents and brothers.

His family issued the following statement:

"Since the age of 13 John has always wanted to become a Royal Marines Commando. He said on many occasions 'I have the best job in the world'. He died a hero following his dream and doing the job he loved. He was proud to be making a difference to both the people of Afghanistan, and to all of us back home who value our freedom. A much loved and always caring son, brother and friend to all those who were fortunate enough to have met him, his death will leave a massive gap in all of our lives. We will not forget him."

Lieutenant Colonel Stuart Birrell RM, Commanding Officer 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Lieutenant John Thornton Royal Marines was in command of the Fire Support Group from Charlie Company, 40 Commando, when he was killed in action at Kajaki, northern Helmand, conducting a patrol to disrupt enemy activity in that area. His death has come as a tremendous shock to his friends and colleagues, and he will be dearly missed by his comrades in 40 Commando Royal Marines.

"John, known universally as 'JT', joined the Royal Marines on 31 August 2004 and made an immediate impact. A conscientious and highly motivated man, he loved the life of a Royal Marine and he very quickly proved himself to be a talented and highly capable Commando officer. Upon completion of Commando training his first appointment was an attachment as a Platoon Commander with the 1st Battalion The Devonshire and Dorset Light Infantry, with whom he deployed to Iraq, serving with distinction during Op TELIC 8.

"He was subsequently appointed to serve with 40 Commando in January 2007 and was thrilled at the prospect of leading Marines on operations. His enthusiasm was infectious and his men responded magnificently to his leadership. An immensely professional officer, throughout his service he was greatly respected by the men under his command.

"During the various operations conducted by Charlie Company, 'JT' was always to be found in the thick of the action; a courageous and brave commander he never asked his men to do anything that he would not do himself. He led from the front and provided an outstanding example to his peers and his men alike; he was a resolute and formidable soldier in battle, a larger than life character who impressed all who met him.

"Lieutenant John Thornton's untimely death is a tragedy; a gregarious, fun-loving man, his passing has caused great sadness across the Royal Marines, and our thoughts are with his parents Linda and Peter, and his brothers Ian and Graham, at this very difficult time."

Major Duncan Manning RM, Officer Commanding Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"'JT' was a central character within the Company. His relaxed and amiable personality made everyone he met immediately warm to him. His good humour and ability to laugh at himself was balanced with high professional skills and a devotion to the men under his command. Never shy of additional workload or responsibility, his laid back style drew the very best from his Marines and he was highly respected as a result of his willingness to listen to, and take advice from, his men.

Lt Thornton on operations in Afghanistan [Picture: MOD]

Lt Thornton on operations in Afghanistan
[Picture: MOD]

"Their well-being and interests were always at the forefront of his mind and he would endeavour to do the best for them. 'JT' became a sounding board and confidante for the new Troop Commanders who arrived mid-tour, listening to their concerns and providing advice when he deemed it appropriate.

"His loyalty, both to his men and to the chain of command, was never in question and this trait when combined with his devotion to his career and constant energy made him a highly effective Royal Marines officer. When in contact with the enemy he remained cool, and his calm voice on the radio would regularly suppress any urge to panic or allow a situation to spiral out of control.

"He was killed as he lived his life, leading from the front and sharing the risks and dangers which his men were required to endure. He was very much looking forward to attending his older brother Ian's Passing Out Parade at the end of his Royal Marines Officer training, and having the opportunity to call him a sprog! JT's loss will be felt by the whole Company and he leaves a gap that will be impossible to fill. He was a true friend in every sense of the word. The thoughts of the whole Company are with his family at this particularly difficult time."

Captain Leon Marshall RM and Lieutenant Alex Nixon RM, 40 Commando Royal Marines, added:

"We will always remember 'JT' for his positive outlook on life. From Day 1 Week 1 of Young Officer Training through until the last time I saw him everything was always 'hoofing'. His enthusiasm was unbreakable, even when the Dartmoor weather was doing its worst. He was immensely proud of his older brother who is currently in Officer Training at the Commando Training Centre, and 'JT' was chuffed to bits at the thought of one day serving alongside him.

"Describing 'JT' as an 'awesome bloke' is a gross understatement. If he could help in any way, he would, no matter the request. I remember during training he worked out that our Survival Exercise was going to be near his house and using true Commando initiative he and a select few managed a shower and BBQ at his house.

"'JT' was an incredible young man who was an exceptional Royal Marine Officer and an unforgettable friend. He will be sorely missed."

Sergeant Darren 'Daz' Joyce, Fire Support Group Troop Sergeant of Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Lieutenant John 'JT' Thornton: A true leader and officer for his men. He led from the front, and in doing so quickly gained the utmost respect from all under his command. Always ready to stand shoulder-to-shoulder in both work and when ashore, be it in DPM or in Spartan Rig. It was an honour to serve alongside him and to call him a friend. He will be sorely missed our Spartan leader and Comrade."

Corporal Dominic 'Cash' Cashman, Fire Support Group Section Commander of Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Lieutenant Thornton: A highly regarded and respected Troop Commander. 'JT' to his friends, he always had time for his charges, making their life easier anyway he could. Never one to shirk his duties he led from the front to inspire young and old members of the Troop alike. Wisdom beyond his years he truly was a leader of men and no words can convey the loss that his passing has brought."

Corporal Aaron 'Tiny' Winter, Section Commander of Charlie Company, said:

"Regarded by the lads as a proper 'Bootneck' Officer, he was liked and respected by the men of his troop and the company throughout. As a section commander in a rifle troop it often instilled confidence in me when his 'Whisky 1' callsign would report over the radio net that they had 'overwatch' as we the ground troops pushed forward. As we pushed forward and often took incoming fire it again was a massive relief and reassurance to hear that 'Whiskey 1' was suppressing enemy positions with Dave Marsh on the Grenade Machine Gun and JT's voice on the radio saying 'That's us suppressing now'."

Marine David 'Dave' Marsh [Picture: MOD]

Marine David 'Dave' Marsh
[Picture: MOD]

Marine David 'Dave' Marsh

Known as 'Dave' to his friends, Marine David Marsh, aged 23, was originally from Sheffield, but had recently moved to Taunton in Somerset with his wife Claire. She said of Marine Marsh:

"David was a loving and dedicated family man. He went though life with a smile on his face, which will continue through our beautiful daughter. The Royal Marines was his passion and love, he will always be our hero."

Marine Marsh’s mother, Maxine, father, Gary and sister Katie said:

"David was a very fine son and brother, he was warm, loving and caring at all times. He was a loving husband and very proud father. He embraced life to the full and no matter what happened his big smile bore him through.

"He was a dedicated Royal Marine and was proud to serve his country. He was much admired and respected by his colleagues for his professionalism and courage. He will be deeply missed by his family and friends and all who knew him."

Lieutenant Colonel Stuart Birrell RM, Commanding Officer of 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Marine Dave Marsh was killed in action at Kajaki, Northern Helmand Province in Afghanistan whilst serving with Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines. Dave joined the Royal Marines on 9 September 2002 and after successfully completing Commando Training at the Commando Training Centre Royal Marines, where he was awarded the Commando Medal for displaying most consistently the attributes expected of a Royal Marines Commando, he was posted to 45 Commando in Scotland where he served with distinction during an operational deployment to Northern Ireland.

"From 45 Commando there followed a period with the Fleet Protection Group Royal Marines, helping to protect the United Kingdom's nuclear deterrent, before he chose to become an Anti-Tank specialist in 2006. Dave joined 40 Commando Royal Marines in December 2006 and immediately impressed with his enthusiastic approach and diligent manner.

"Throughout pre-deployment training and the exceptionally difficult challenges he faced during his company's tour of duty in Afghanistan, his resolve and determination to succeed in all he undertook was truly breathtaking. A consummate professional he was deeply respected in his company; in battle he was steadfast and utterly dependable, in barracks he was a true friend and comrade whose presence was a comfort in difficult times.

"Marine Dave Marsh has been cruelly taken from us and he will be sadly missed by all who had the privilege to know him. A loving, compassionate husband and father, he will be dearly missed by his wife Claire and his young daughter Molly, along with his parents Gary and Maxine, and his sister Katie; our thoughts and prayers are with them at this most difficult and distressing time."

Major Duncan Manning RM, Officer Commanding Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Marine Dave Marsh was an inspiration to the whole Company. A larger than life character, he was known by all, and respected by both peers and commanders alike. For him the glass was always half full and regardless of conditions he remained positive. The one thing that always struck you when you saw Mne Marsh, regardless of the time of day, was his smile that appeared to be ever-present, lifting the morale for those around.

"When times were hard or conditions difficult Dave Marsh would invariably make a comment or tell an amusing anecdote, which invariably made you laugh. His ready wit and good humour were balanced however with high professional skills and a devotion to his chosen profession. He could regularly be seen behind the aiming sight of his Javelin missile system maintaining his focus for hours on end.

"It was due to his experience and proven proficiency that he was regularly chosen to assume the position of a vehicle commander, directing his WMIK vehicle with confidence and authority. If any member of his Troop were to find themselves in a difficult and dangerous situation it was Dave Marsh they wanted by their side. It is for this reason that his Troop commander selected Dave to be his driver.

"Marine Dave Marsh or 'Comedy Dave' was an outstanding character and a true 'Bootneck'. Committed to his family and work, socially he was always there to lift spirits when times were hard. An all round hoofing Bootneck it has been an honour to work with him and call him a friend. His tragic death is a huge loss to everyone who had the pleasure to know him."

Sergeant Darren 'Daz' Joyce, Fire Support Group Troop Sergeant, Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines

"His loss is made especially difficult being so close to the end of the tour having faced so many dangers on numerous previous occasions. The thoughts and prayers of the whole company go out to those he has left behind, particularly his wife Claire and his daughter Molly. While the Company cannot be there in person to help and support his family, we are thinking of them at this difficult time."

Warrant Officer First Class Neil 'Brum' Warrington, Assistant Adjutant of 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Dave was the epitome of a Royal Marine who upheld all the qualities of a true Commando, in particular 'Cheerfulness in Adversity'. He always had a smile on his face that lifted the spirits of everyone around him, in any situation. You never knew what was coming next with Dave. This uncertainty earned him the nickname 'Crazy Dave' whilst serving in Zulu Company, 45 Commando, and a nickname he loved to live up to.

"He had a streak of devilment in him that kept everyone on their toes, as he loved to play pranks on anyone who let their guard down. He was the character that every Royal Marine Company needed and every Sergeant Major loved to have around, for so many different reasons. This man loved life and everyone who knew him will always smile at that thought. On behalf of the men you served with in Zulu Company and all the other Royal Marines that were blessed with your friendship, you will be missed, but never forgotten."

Sergeant Darren 'Daz' Joyce, Fire Support Group Troop Sergeant, Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Marine Dave Marsh or 'Comedy Dave' was an outstanding character and a true 'Bootneck'. Committed to his family and work, socially he was always there to lift spirits when times were hard. An all round hoofing Bootneck it has been an honour to work with him and call him a friend. His tragic death is a huge loss to everyone who had the pleasure to know him."

Corporal Dominic 'Cash' Cashman, Fire Support Group Section Commander, Charlie Company, said:

"Larger than life Dave 'Billy the Kid' will be remembered for his boundless energy and manic character. A permanent source of morale for his fellow marines, his professionalism was without question and doing his job so well made my job so much easier. A better example of a Bootneck could not be found. Working with Dave he continually demonstrated his love for his family and balance for both work and home alike. Dave was the brightest light and a light that affected anyone around him. He will be sorely missed."

Corporal Aaron 'Tiny' Winter, Rifle Troop Section Commander, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"'Crazy' Dave Marsh: A man who was always smiling in contact with the enemy or whilst firing the Grenade Machine Gun, playing poker or smoking his pipe. The only time that his smile changed was when he spoke of his daughter Molly whereupon his smile would double in size and his face would beam with pride. Despite the nickname of 'Crazy' Dave he astounded many in the company by fixing the lads' laptops with his leatherman tool and a can lid, when many a qualified technician had failed; there was much much more to this man than met the eye. He will be sorely missed by the Kajaki Pipe Smokers whose daily after dinner smoking sessions were improved with his attendance and humour."

Marine Andrew 'Charlie' Charlesworth, Storeman for Charlie Company, 40 Commando Royal Marines, said:

"Dave Marsh, what I can say about him. I have only known him about eight months but what I can say is that he had the ability to make you laugh even when you did not want to. His infectious laugh, character and zest for life were memorable and only Dave could have that got away with that 'Billy the Kid tattoo'. I am pretty sure that God will be laughing with Dave right now."

Des Browne, Secretary of State for Defence, said:

"I was extremely saddened to hear of the deaths of Lieutenant John Thornton and Marine David Marsh. Both of them embodied the skills and qualities central to the Royal Marines ethos and their loss will resonate amongst all who knew them. My thoughts are with all their family, friends and comrades as they struggle to come to terms with their loss."

19 Feb 2008

Soldier from 2nd Battalion The Yorksh...

Soldier from 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment killed in Helmand

18 Feb 08

It is with deep regret that the Ministry of Defence must confirm that a soldier from the 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment was killed in southern Afghanistan yesterday, Sunday 17 February 2008.

MOD Announcement. Opens in a new window.

Ministry of Defence

One other soldier was also injured in the incident but his injuries are not life threatening.

Just before 2100 hrs local time soldiers from the 2nd Battalion The Yorkshire Regiment, as part of their Operational Mentoring and Liaison Team (OMLT) role, were taking part in a foot patrol with 40 Commando Royal Marines near Kajaki, Helmand Province, when they were caught in an explosion.

Medical treatment was administered at the scene and both soldiers were evacuated to Camp Bastion by emergency response helicopter. Sadly one of the soldiers was pronounced dead on arrival.

Next of kin have been informed and there will be 24 hour period of grace before further details are released.

15 Feb 2008

Coroner attacks MoD over failure

Coroner attacks MoD over failure
Captain James Philippson
Captain James Philippson was killed by Taleban fighters in Afghanistan

A coroner criticised the Ministry of Defence for failing to supply soldiers in Afghanistan with basic equipment.

The comments came at the end of an inquest in Oxford into the death of Captain James Philippson, 29, who died in a firefight with Taleban fighters.

Andrew Walker said 7 Parachute Regiment Royal Horse Artillery was defeated by the "lack of basic equipment."

Capt Philippson, of Hertfordshire, was the first casualty after troops were deployed in the region in June 2006.

The inquest heard how, before the incident on 11 June, 7 Para soldiers had complained repeatedly about a lack of proper equipment - chiefly standard night vision kits and weaponry.

Mr Walker, assistant coroner for Oxfordshire, said: "They (the soldiers) were defeated not by the terrorists but by the lack of basic equipment."

He said sending troops into a combat zone without basic kit was "unforgivable and inexcusable" and "a breach of trust between the soldiers and those who govern them".

The Treasury and the then Chancellor, Gordon Brown, will be really to blame for what happened
Anthony Philippson

He recorded a narrative verdict in which he said Capt Philippson was unlawfully killed.

During the inquest Mr Walker asked Major Johnny Bristow, Capt Philippson's commanding officer, if they would have been a match for their attackers had they been supplied with Minimi machine guns and under-slung grenade launchers.

"It would have made a hell of a difference," Major Bristow said.

He said there were three or four kits between as many as 30 men.

The hearing was told that the Taleban forces had multiple rocket-propelled grenade launchers and a wealth of other firepower.

'Outgunned by terrorists'

But even after his death, the much-needed equipment did not arrive, the hearing was told.

Capt Philippson's father, Anthony Philippson, said after the verdict: "He (the coroner) laid into them, particularly badly for the lack of equipment.

"They were outgunned by a bunch of terrorists. I do hold the Ministry of Defence (MoD) responsible for James's death but it is not just the MoD - it goes much deeper than that.

"The Treasury and the then chancellor, Gordon Brown, will be really to blame for what happened.

"It's not really the MoD who are responsible - it's that miserable, harsh, parsimonious Scotsman we now have as prime minister who starved the MoD of funds."

'Starved of cash'

Capt Philippson was part of a quick-reaction force dispatched to assist another group of British soldiers who had come under fire after they were sent to retrieve an unmanned aerial reconnaissance vehicle (UAV) which had come down.

As he ran to help, Capt Philippson was hit in the temple by a bullet. Cause of death was given as a gunshot wound to the head.

The troops were deployed in Afghanistan to help train soldiers from the Afghan national army with a view to them controlling the Sangin area of Helmand Province, where 7 Para were based.

7 Feb 2008

Sickness thins the ranks of troops on...

Sickness thins the ranks of troops on front line


By Thomas Harding, Defence Correspondent
Last Updated: 1:56am GMT 05/02/2008

Almost 7,000 infantrymen are unfit to fight, leaving front-line troops "dangerously exposed," figures show today.


Frontline: Our troops in Iraq and AfghanistanAfghan fury over British training for ex-Taliban

One in 14 soldiers is sick or injured at a time when every regiment of 600 faces a shortfall of 100 men because of problems with recruitment and the numbers leaving the Army.

 
British troops in Helmand province, Afghanistan
The seriousness of the shortages faced by the Army is highlighted in the spring deployment to Afghanistan

Troop shortages are so acute that at least six battalions are being sent to do the job of four battalions when the next brigade deploys to Afghanistan this spring, The Daily Telegraph can disclose.

Commanding officers waiting for reinforcements for infantry units in Helmand have been told to wait until 17-year-old soldiers turned 18, the legal landmark to qualify for the battlefield.

Liam Fox, the shadow defence secretary, said the Government had overstretched the Armed Forces to the point where it produced "some very real consequences on our abilities to fight on the front line". The shortages could "endanger the safety of personnel" and indicated a "retention crisis" in the military.

For at least a year, military chiefs have been aware that the strain of two substantial missions in Iraq and Afghanistan would prove a massive drain on manpower and now the Armed Forces are at the very limit of being able to provide personnel for the front line.The Ministry of Defence was told in a critical Commons defence committee report that the Forces were losing large numbers of experienced personnel fed up with constantly being away from home.

The "serious worries" of the committee are reflected in the new figures, obtained by the Tory MP Patrick Mercer, that show one in 14 infantrymen is "unfit to deploy".

The figures, given in a written statement, are taken from 10 battalions that were in Iraq or Afghanistan last year or are now on operations.

They show that 2nd Bn Yorkshire Regiment has left behind 50 long-term sick troops while the battalion is fighting in Helmand province. In Iraq last year 1st Regiment Royal Horse Artillery had almost 10 per cent of its 388 gunners unfit for duty.

"This is an albatross that hangs over commanding officers' heads," said Mr Mercer, a former infantry commander. "In times of peace it is fine but in war it is a complete and utter liability.

"The MoD say they are 4,000 below strength but the truth is that there are two brigade's worth of long-term sick who cannot deploy and are simply a liability."

Reflected across the Army, the figures from the 10 battalions would mean the Service could field only 90,000 men out of a required total of 101,800.

The Army is already 3,800 short of its desired manning level because of soldiers leaving.

Mr Mercer said under-manning was "crippling the Army" and the situation had to be addressed immediately.

Cdr John Muxworthy, of the UK National Defence Association, which is campaigning for higher defence spending, said: "It is unfair to the troops, the Armed Forces, and the country and something has to be done.

"The MoD has conceded that the Forces are 'stretched', but not that there is excessive stretch. Nobody will admit that it's down to chronic under-funding and under-manning."

Col Bob Stewart, who commanded British forces in Bosnia, said: "They need more rest, more training and more time off operational duty.

"The fact is that they are knackered. The operational commitments are so great now that people - particularly in the infantry - have not been able to recoup and retrain.

"As a soldier you must be given the chance to rest otherwise you are exhausted. And if you are exhausted you are far more likely to get sick."

The seriousness of the shortages is highlighted in the spring deployment to Afghanistan, which will be announced in Parliament this week.

To bring the four infantry battalions in 16 Air Assault Brigade up to full strength elements of at least three extra units will also be deployed.

The Royal Highland Fusiliers, 2nd Scots, will provide extra cover but will have to merge two companies to form the Kabul Patrol Group commitment. At least one extra platoon is expected to be provided by 1 Rifles, who already have 100-strong companies in Gibraltar and the Falklands.

Brig Mark Carleton-Smith, 16 Brigade's commander, is said also to have requested The Highlanders, 4th Scots, to hold the recently recaptured town of Musa Qala against a possible Taliban assault this summer. The battalion is supposed to be deploying to Iraq.

"We need to hold the ground we have taken," an Army source said. "But this is leading to a bit of a patchwork quilt of battalions."

An Army spokesman said: "The forces pride themselves on their fitness and are well known for it but there will always be a small element

suffering from sickness or injury and not fit to deploy to an operational theatre."

The use of elements from a number of battalions was "not new" and battle casualty replacements were "provided as and when required by the Chain of Command".

UKNDA require members!

Page 1
UKNDA Limited: Reg no. 6254639
Website: www.uknda.org
UK NATIONAL DEFENCE ASSOCIATION
President: Winston S Churchill
Patrons:
Admiral Lord Boyce GCB OBE DL
Rt. Hon Sir Menzies Campbell CBE QC MP
Marshal of the RAF Lord Craig GCB OBE MA DSc
General Lord Guthrie GCB LVO OBE
Rt. Hon Lord Owen CH
Chairman & CE: Cdr. J L Muxworthy, RN
UKNDA Ltd., PO Box 819
Portsmouth, Hants PO1 9FF
e-mail: ceo@uknda.org
FEBRUARY 2008 NEWSLETTER
My Lords, Ladies & Gentlemen – Patrons, Vice Presidents, Members and
Registered Supporters of the UKNDA…..
Herewith your regular monthly update on UKNDA affairs. But first a request:
As at 3 Feb 08 we had 909 active (i.e. paid up) members, 257 inactive (still to pay)
members, and 676 registered supporters; a total of 1842. I did not write 'Grand total'
because we can, and will with your help, do very much better than that. Indeed we
must increase our numbers very significantly if we are to effectively influence (with
potential votes) our politicians. Our politicians must raise 'Defence & the Armed
Forces' much higher in the Nation's list of priorities to provide us with sufficient,
appropriate and fully funded Armed Forces… which we do not now have.
Our immediate target is for a total of 10,000 UKNDA members/registered supporters
– and then, to achieve REAL effective influence, 100,000.
If, immediately you have finished reading this newsletter, every one of you would
take just half an hour to send out a very brief e-mail to all of your friends and
colleagues whom you have not yet contacted – then we could double our numbers in a
week! I offer you the following form of words that you might care to use:
Dear …… I believe you would wish to know about the United Kingdom National
Defence Association (UKNDA) – of which I am a member/supporter. I attach a one
page article about the Association (attached to this e-mail) for you to consider. I do
hope you will wish to join us because our Country and our Armed Forces need our
active support now and for the future. Yours sincerely……
UKNDA Limited: Reg no. 6254639
Website: www.uknda.org
PROGRESS REPORT:
The following activities and 'projects' are underway or being planned:
First (pilot scheme) UKNDA Regional Branch meeting – Warminster (Wilts)
Assembly Rooms 1900 for 1930 – Wednesday 13
th
February
As previously announced, and following requests from a number of members
throughout the Country, as an initial 'pilot project' we are holding the first ever
Regional Branch meeting of the UKNDA in Warminster (details above) on 13
th
February. All UKNDA members and supporters and their friends and colleagues
in and around the Warminster area are invited to attend. Please contact the local
branch Chairman, Grant Chamberlain (
) if you wish to
attend so that appropriate seating arrangements can be made. Dr Andrew Murrison,
MP for Westbury will attend and speak, as will I and others to publicise the UKNDA
and plan the 'way ahead' for similar branches throughout the whole Kingdom.
Do come - the more the merrier (the bar will be open after the meeting!)
TV Series? This is just to tell you that the possibility and concept of a TV
programme (or even series) about the UKNDA is being actively explored. I will keep
you advised in future Newsletters as to our progress.
VOLUNTEERS WANTED! We have an urgent need to fill the following part-time
voluntary posts to join the 'Executive' of the UKNDA. If you can spare just a few
hours each week and have the necessary interest, enthusiasm, appropriate general
background (you do not need to be an 'expert' – you can learn on the job) and really
want to DO something practical to help us….. E-mail me now with brief personal
details and your telephone number: ceo@uknda.org
UKNDA In-house Public Relations Officer.
UKNDA In-house Marketing Manager.
At least 3 new Board Members to represent 'Army Interests'
POLL/SURVEY OF ALL MPs. Progress is being made towards sending a letter
and a short questionnaire to every MP in the UK to find out what their views are
regarding 'Defence & our Armed Forces'. We will analyse and publicise their replies
throughout the media and thus to their constituents. We should then have a broad
overall picture of the 'views of the House' and know more accurately how high a
mountain it is that we have to climb.
INCREASE 'LINKS' & ASSOCIATIONS. In the next month we plan to start
contacting all of the hundreds of Service Charities and Military Associations and
Clubs inviting them all to exchange LINKS with the UKNDA and join us, either
formally or informally, in our campaign to "Support Our Armed Forces".
"SUPPORT OUR ARMED FORCES" CAMPAIGN. We are initiating a 'Support
Our Armed Forces Campaign' and by the end of this month we hope to have a new
web-site (related to and inter-woven with our existing web-site) with the address:
UKNDA Limited: Reg no. 6254639
Website: www.uknda.org
www.supportourarmedforces.org.uk Please note that address is NOT yet
live/active – but you will all be sent an e-mail when it is.
CAR STICKERS A UKNDA Board Member, Paul Medhurst, who lives and works
in Vienna, is designing a "Support Our Armed Forces" car sticker. This sticker will
display that slogan, our logo and our web-site address. We intend to send one sticker
out FREE to every member (which will cost us at least £1 a head) and members and
supporters will then be able to purchase more stickers for further onward distribution.
The 'COVENANT'. Although not initiated by the UKNDA, Gary Blackburn, a
UKNDA Board member, is arranging a Conference to discuss and debate the
'Covenant' – this conference to be held at Hull University, probably on 29
th
May.
More details will be promulgated nearer the time.
FUNDRAISING Planning for various Fund raising events is progressing, and
appropriate details of such events will be publicised when arrangements, dates, venues
etc are firmed up.
WEB-SITE. You will very soon see a revised/updated HOME PAGE to our existing
web-site. Also, while we already try to post 'latest news items' on the front page, we
know that we must develop an organisation whereby we keep on top of latest
developments. There is still room for improvements and let me assure you that we are
working to make them. Not only will we soon 'bolt on' the new "Support Our Armed
Forces" web-site (as already described) we will then move on to develop the long
promised Members-Only Forum/Chat Room. Watch this space, or rather - watch the
web-site.
After the excitements of our launch followed by the House of Lords' Debate on
Defence, if it might appear to you that perhaps things have 'gone a bit quiet' on the
UKNDA front – you would be both right and wrong. A lot of action is going on
'behind the scenes' to ensure that we have in place the sound management and
administrative organisation needed to drive the UKNDA onwards and upwards. I was
asked the other day "How long do you think there will be a need for the UKNDA -
Five years?"….. and my reply was – "We will be needed for a generation at least".
This is a long and hard road that we have to travel and it is absolutely crucial that we
make haste, but steadily, to ensure that we get things right at the first attempt.
It's going to be a busy 2008 which will go quicker and more productively if you will
all now send out this message and the page below to all your friends and colleagues:
WE ARE THE UKNDA – DO JOIN US –
YOUR COUNTRY & OUR ARMED FORCES REALLY DO NEED YOU.
Sincerely –
John Muxworthy
CEO UKNDA
UKNDA Limited: Reg no. 6254639
Website: www.uknda.org
UNITED KINGDOM NATIONAL
UNITED KINGDOM NATIONAL
UNITED KINGDOM NATIONAL
UNITED KINGDOM NATIONAL
DEFENCE
DEFENCE
DEFENCE
DEFENCE ASSOCIATION
ASSOCIATION
ASSOCIATION
ASSOCIATION
You will have read in the papers and seen on the
television how our Armed Forces are over-stretched
and under-resourced. In Iraq, Afghanistan and
elsewhere they defend us and our national interests at
great risk to themselves and too often at the cost of
their lives
The UK National Defence Association (UKNDA) has been created to…
…. campaign for sufficient, appropriate and fully funded
Armed Forces that the Nation needs to defend effectively its
people, their security and vital interests at home and worldwide.
The UKNDA contends that the following issues must be addressed
because, as a former Prince of Wales once famously declared:
"Something must be done!"
1.
'Defence' is too low in the Nation's list of priorities and therefore the
Armed Forces are under resourced (under funded) for the tasks they are set.
2.
This results in inter-Service wrangles over an inadequate budget.
3.
Over tasking and under resourcing leads to our Armed Forces being
over-stretched and, from time to time, to suffer from equipment
shortages and/or failures. These factors can, and do, result all too often
in unnecessary casualties.
4.
All of the above lead to increasing pressures on the most important element
of our Armed Forces – the serving men and women (and their families)
who do the work, face the threats and risk their lives to defend us.
Have YOU ever served in the Armed Forces?
Are YOU related to anyone who is serving or has served?
Are YOU concerned about the effective Defence of our country and our people?
Said "Yes" to any of these questions? Then the UKNDA needs YOU.
JOIN THE UKNDA NOW
(You do NOT need to have served in our Armed Forces to join the UKNDA)
Our web-site www.uknda.org will tell you all about the
UKNDA and you can 'sign up' there - or you can write to
UKNDA Ltd. PO Box 819, Portsmouth, PO1 9FF
HELP DO THAT 'SOMETHING' THAT MUST BE DONE

3 Feb 2008

Fall back, men, Afghanistan is a nast...

Fall back, men, Afghanistan is a nasty war we can never win

Britain's commanders ignored every warning that the Taliban were the toughest fighters on earth

The American secretary of state, Condoleezza Rice, flies to Britain this week to meet a crisis entirely of London and Washington's creation. They have no strategy for the continuing occupation of Afghanistan. They are hanging on for dear life and praying for something to turn up. Britain is repeating the experience of Gordon in Khartoum, of the Dardanelles, Singapore and Crete, of politicians who no longer read history expecting others to die for their dreams of glory.

Every independent report on the Nato-led operation in Afghanistan cries the same message: watch out, disaster beckons. Last week America's Afghanistan Study Group, led by generals and diplomats of impeccable credentials, reported on "a weakening international resolve and a growing lack of confidence". An Atlantic Council report was more curt: "Make no mistake, Nato is not winning in Afghanistan." The country was in imminent danger of becoming a failed state.

A clearly exasperated Robert Gates, the American defence secretary, has broken ranks with the official optimism and committed an extra 3,000 marines to the field, while sending an "unusually stern" note to Germany demanding that its 3,200 troops meet enemy fire. Germany, like France, has rejected that plea. Yet it is urgent since the Canadians have threatened to withdraw from the south if not relieved. An equally desperate Britain is proposing to send half-trained territorials to the front, after its commanders ignored every warning that the Taliban were the toughest fighters on earth.

Meanwhile Nato is doing what it does best, squabbling. Gates has criticised Britain for not taking the war against the insurgents with sufficient vigour. Britain is furious at America's obsession with spraying the Helmand poppy crop and thus destroying all hope of winning hearts and minds. Most of the 37,000 soldiers wandering round Kabul were sent on the understanding that they would do no fighting. No army was ever assembled on so daft a premise.

Nato's much-vaunted 2006 strategy has not worked. It boasted that its forces would only be guarding reconstruction and training the Afghan police. There would be no more counterproductive airstrikes against Pashtun villages. The Taliban would be countered by American special forces, with the Pakistan army attacking their rear. Two years ago anyone expressing scepticism towards this rosy scenario was greeted at Nato headquarters in Kabul with guffaws of laughter. Today that laughter must be music in Taliban ears.

Kabul is like Saigon at the end of the Vietnam war. It swarms with refugees and corruption while an upper crust of well-heeled contractors, consultants and NGO groupies careers from party to party in bullet-proof Land Cruisers. Spin doctors fighting a daily battle with the truth have resorted to enemy kill-rates to imply victory, General Westmoreland's ploy in Vietnam.

This is a far cry from Britain's 2001 pledges of opium eradication, gender-awareness and civic-governance classes. After 87 deaths and two years of operations in Helmand, the British Army cannot even secure one dam. Aid successes such as a few new schools and roads in the north look ever more tenuous as the country detaches itself from Kabul and tribal elders struggle to make terms with Taliban commanders.

There is plainly no way 6,000 British troops are ever going to secure, let alone pacify, the south. More soldiers will simply evince more insurgency. More American raids across the Pakistan border merely offer propaganda to Al-Qaeda in its radicalisation of the tribal areas. It was just such brutalism that preceded the Soviet escalation of the counterinsurgency war in the 1980s, and the rise of the (American-backed) precursors of the Taliban.

The best news out of Kabul is the increased disenchantment of the wily Afghan president, Hamid Karzai. Last week he vetoed the West's offering of a former leader of Britain's Liberal Democrats, Lord Ashdown, to co-ordinate operations in Kabul, whatever that might mean. Liberal democracy is not high on Karzai's priority list.

He attacked the British for drawing the Taliban into his unregulated domain. When outside agents were thought to be negotiating with Taliban elements behind his back, he instantly expelled them from the country.

Meanwhile he has taken to making his own choice of provincial governors and commanders, often warlords enmeshed in the booming drugs trade. That trade offers Afghanistan its one staple income.

While the international community in Kabul wails that Karzai is too close to the druglords, the warlords and various sinister Taliban go-betweens, they are at least his warlords and his go-betweens. When Britain sacked the ruthless tribal chief, Sher Mohammed Akhundzada, as governor of Helmand, Karzai was furious and rightly predicted it would lead to a surge in Taliban aggression.

For all his faults, Karzai is both an elected leader and a canny one. He is a virtual prisoner of the Nato garrison in Kabul but Afghanistan remains his country and if he thinks he can cut deals across its political heartlands, let him. If he wants Nato to stop bombing Taliban bases in Pashtun villages and killing Pashtun tribal leaders, then it should stop.

Withdraw the opium eradication teams from Helmand. Let Karzai barter money for power and power for peace. The foreign "governance" pundits in Kabul might dream of Afghanistan as a latterday Sweden, but they are never going to bring Pashtuns, Baluchis, Tajiks, Hazaras and Uzbeks into a stable federation.

Only an Afghan stands any chance of doing that, and the one Afghan on offer is Karzai.

Common sense advocates a demilitarisation of the occupation, with a withdrawal of western troops to Kabul where they can try to protect the capital and the northern trade routes. In provinces to the south and east, Karzai's money, weapons and negotiating skills must deliver what results they can. The West cannot possibly police Afghanistan with anything remotely like the resources it has available.

Behind such a policy shift should lie an even more crucial one. For the past two decades intelligence lore has held that nothing happens along the Afghan/Pakistan frontier without agencies of the Pakistan army being involved. The latter's pro-Taliban strategy through the 1990s was based on its obsession with "defence in depth" against India. Pakistan wanted Afghanistan stable, friendly and medieval. The security of the Punjab rested on the containment of the Pashtun tribal lands straddling the Pakistan/ Afghanistan border.

George W Bush's reckless elevation of Al-Qaeda after 2001 promoted a small group of alien Arab guests into global warriors for Islam. It also destroyed Islamabad's hold over the Taliban. America bribed the Pakistan president Pervez Musharraf with $1 billion a year to declare a U-turn and fight his former allies.

Musharraf duly broke his non-intervention treaty with the Pashtun and sent his army against them. The Taliban's influence increases with every attack and with every American bombing of villages. The Pakistan army is suffering greater losses in this war than either the British or the Americans.

Wise heads in Islamabad know that they must withdraw from the border and restore respect for tribal autonomy. Nothing else will incline the Pashtun and other tribes to reject Al-Qaeda and its Taliban allies. The alternative is a growing insurgency that must destabilise whatever democratic regime might emerge from this month's Pakistan elections. That prospect is far worse than whatever fate might befall Afghanistan.

There is no sensible alternative to ending military operations against the Pashtun, flying under whatever flag. Like Iraq's Kurdistan, Pashtunistan is a country without a state. It has been cursed by history, but it returns that curse with interest when attacked. Fate has now handed it a starring role in Britain's nastiest war in decades, and offered it the power to wreck an emergent democracy of vital interest to the West.

To have set one of the world's most ancient and ferocious people on the warpath against both Kabul and Islamabad takes some doing. But western diplomacy has done it. Now must begin the agonising process of escaping that appalling mistake.